How many times have you visited a website and had the reaction: Wow! That’s a great-looking site. I wonder what they do. Aside from sites that look like a haphazard collection of unrelated content, I bet you’re asking that question at more than half of the sites you see. I know I am. And it really bothers me.
It seems so simple, so basic. Just like the other communications we’ve discussed in this series, your website—especially the M1— isn’t about you. It’s about your prospect’s problem. That section must immediately answer three key questions: What do you offer? Why should I care? What’s the next step? If yours says something like, “We’ve been innovators since 1982” or “Save money on your health insurance,” you are creating noise, not clear messaging.
Websites that make sense
As a StoryBrand Certified Coach, I help clients prioritize their messages. You might be surprised to learn that there are website templates specifically designed for StoryBrand content.
The M1—or “Message One”—is the first thing a visitor notices when they land on your site. It’s the digital equivalent of a firm handshake and eye contact. You have seconds—literally seconds—to capture someone’s attention and convey three key points:
1. You understand their problem.
2. You offer a solution.
3. There’s a clear and simple next step.
Anything less, and you’re likely to lose them to the back button. Or worse, the competition.
Now, let’s discuss the real problem: design-driven delusion. Too many companies fall in love with the *look* of their site. They hire costly designers who produce eye-catching visuals—slick animations, cinematic images, minimalist fonts—but overlook the part where the site is meant to *function*. That’s not a website. That’s a brochure. And a confusing one at that.
Pretty isn’t persuasive
Here’s the harsh truth: your audience doesn’t care how attractive your website is if they can’t understand what you actually do. Visual appeal matters—but only if it enhances clarity. No one ever said, “I hired that company because their Arial Bold made me feel something.” They said, “I knew exactly what they offered, and it was the solution I was looking for.”
Compare two websites:
– One is a $25,000 custom design with hero videos, a parallax scroll, and artsy taglines like “Creating impact through transformation.”
– The other features a simple, clean layout with a headline that says, “We help small business owners lower their tax bill without switching CPAs.”
Guess which one gets the lead?
We need to stop confusing *polish* with *purpose*.
The Curse of Cleverness
Clever taglines are another common trap. Messaging like “Turning ideas into reality,” “Empowering your journey,” or “Innovating the future of solutions” sounds fancy. But none of it tells your visitor what you actually do. These phrases are like the air-freshener aisle at the grocery store—lots of different scents, but none of them help you clean your kitchen.
A clear message always beats a clever one. If you confuse, you lose.
Your Website’s Job
Your homepage has one main job: to qualify and convert visitors. That doesn’t mean it should try to tell your entire story. It should *filter*. When your M1 is functioning properly, the right people will stay, and the wrong ones will leave. That’s not a problem. That’s *effective*.
When someone lands on your site, they’re asking three subconscious questions:
– Am I in the right place?
– Can you help me solve my problem?
– What do I do next?
If your site doesn’t answer those questions in the first few seconds, you’ve missed the mark. No matter how polished or pretty it is.
Instead of hiding your offer beneath layers of vague marketing copy and design fluff, a StoryBrand-based template leads with empathy, followed by authority, then a clear call to action.
It’s not magic. It’s structure. And structure drives results.
Things they don’t care about.
Remember, your visitor isn’t reading your site to learn about your journey, awards, or passion. They’re there because they have a problem and hope you’re the one to solve it. If your site forces them to work to figure that out, they’ll leave.
When you focus your messaging on *the client’s* journey—and position yourself as the guide—you build trust. You become relevant. You turn visitors into customers.
But when you start with “We’ve been around since the Reagan administration,” or “We’re passionate about what we do,” your prospect hears: “This site is about them, not me.”
And they bounce.
In summary:
-
Great design plus a clear message equals a winning website.
-
Great design without a clear message is polished, pretty, and pointless.
-
Messaging always comes first. Always.
So go ahead—choose your favorite font, pick your brand colors, and add a beautiful hero image. But if your M1 doesn’t say what you do, who you do it for, and why it matters—start over. Your website shouldn’t be a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an animation.
Your website should be a window to the client’s problem: clear, focused, and unmissable. If it isn’t, you’re on mute!
TURN CORPORATE BABBLE INTO BUYER BAIT!
Discover how we can help you cut through the noise, reach the right customers, and keep your pipelines full.
SCHEDULE a 30-minute discovery call, and ask about our special offer for Substack subscribers.
One More Thing
For you TL;DR folks (you know who you are), check out our YouTube Snarky Summaries. (please LIKE and SUBSCRIBE)
